Heavy Cream vs. Whipping Cream: Best Choice for Cheesecake

• Written by Aug, 4 2025
• 0 Comments

If you’ve ever squinted at your supermarket’s dairy section, debating between heavy cream and whipping cream, you’re not alone. You grab your trolley, heart set on baking the best cheesecake your family’s ever tasted, and—bam!—these two white cartons stare back at you with their nearly-identical labels, only separated by a single word. It’s enough to make you call your mum, Google desperately, or just freeze and pick a tub of ice cream instead. Truth is, this tiny choice changes a lot, and surprisingly, even seasoned bakers argue over which cream gives that trademark silky, dreamy cheesecake texture every time.

What Sets Heavy Cream and Whipping Cream Apart?

Let’s not sugarcoat it—the main thing separating heavy cream and whipping cream is fat content. According to Australia’s Food Standards Code, heavy cream (sometimes called thickened cream Down Under) must contain at least 36% milk fat, while whipping cream ranges between 30% and 35%. That minor-sounding percentage packs a punch for your desserts. The fat is what gives baked cheesecakes their gorgeously rich, mouth-coating feel and ensures the texture turns out smooth as satin, not stiff or chalky. More fat means better emulsification with your cream cheese, creating a fuller mouthfeel and minimizing cracks or dryness.

Whipping cream, though “lighter,” does whip well and adds airiness, but it can’t always deliver that dense, decadent structure you might crave in a proper New York-style cheesecake. If you’re going for Japanese cotton cheesecake, it’s a different story, but for classic bakes, heavy cream is the gold standard. To illustrate the impact of these seemingly subtle differences, check out this quick comparison:

The thing is, cream isn’t just cream. Australian “thickened cream” can have gelling agents that mimic extra fat, while American or European heavy creams are purer but don’t whip quite as firm. That’s why you sometimes see different results following a recipe from an American blog using an Aussie carton. The additives like gelatin, xanthan gum, or vegetable gums in local heavy creams are actually there to help make up for lower fat and boost stability—sneaky but handy if you struggle with getting perfect slices.

Think about it this way: the more fat, the less likely you’ll end up with a grainy mess or a watery, sagging cheesecake. Even professional pastry chefs in Melbourne argue at length about whether additives matter for flavor, but for a home baker, the difference in the finished product is clear. It’s the difference between a just-okay cheesecake and one that gets you recipe requests at every family event.

How Cream Type Affects Cheesecake Texture, Flavor, and Structure

When you’re chasing that cheesecake you can’t stop thinking about—the kind that’s dense yet fluffy, smooth but never rubbery—it’s the fat from heavy cream that does the heavy lifting. Fat acts as a carrier for flavor, so your cheesecake doesn’t just taste creamy; it holds onto vanilla, lemon zest, and even the Golden Gaytime crumb crust you might add on the base (trust me, it’s an Aussie staple you’ve got to try).

Heavy cream gives baked cheesecakes their classic, melt-in-the-mouth bite. When combined with cream cheese, eggs, and sugar, it forms a thick batter that bakes evenly, resisting curdling or separations. This matters when you’re transporting a cheesecake from the oven to the fridge and finally onto a plate—it stays together without suffering the heartbreak of a cracked top. If you freeze your cheesecake to get that last-minute dessert out the door for a party, heavy cream keeps it from becoming icy or gritty when you thaw it. That’s the hidden power of higher fat.

Whipping cream whips faster (hence the name) due to its lower fat, so it brings more air and lightness. Maybe that sounds perfect if you love airy mousses and light no-bake cheesecakes, but if the cream isn’t quite fatty enough, the texture doesn’t set as firmly. You risk a soft set—think spreadable, rather than sliceable. That’s not ideal for classic cheesecakes you’d find in a Melbourne bakery or at your Nonna’s house. And let’s not even talk about the time my mate tried making a cheesecake for her vegan friend, subbing in coconut cream, only to have the whole thing collapse at the Summer BBQ. Not all cream is created equal, and if you’re not fussy about firmness, you could be missing out on the proper dessert experience.

But here’s a trick for those who only have whipping cream in the fridge: try adding a tablespoon of melted butter per cup of whipping cream. It bumps up the fat content, giving you a texture closer to heavy cream. It won’t magically create the heft of a proper thickened cream, but it gets you a lot closer in a pinch. For those obsessed with silky cheesecakes, you can even use sour cream or full fat Greek yogurt to give an extra tartness and density that compliments the cream, fat, and cheese combo. Ever heard of a ricotta cheesecake from Nonna’s recipes? That’s another brilliant way to tweak texture without losing richness. Play around and blend creams—the kitchen was made for experiments.

Tips for Buying, Using, and Substituting Creams in Cheesecake

Baker’s tip: Always start with cream that’s as fresh as possible. Cream with a closer sell-by date can whip up with an odd, slightly tangy flavor, and nobody wants unexpected cheese funk sneaking into your dessert. If you’re in Melbourne or elsewhere in Australia, note that “thickened cream” is often the best supermarket sub for heavy cream in American recipes, since most of our shops don’t carry “heavy” cream under that label. Double cream (48% fat or higher) is incredibly rich and best saved for dolloping rather than baking—way too thick to blend evenly into a cheesecake mix unless you thin it out first.

If you need to substitute one cream for another, don’t just switch cup for cup. As I mentioned earlier, you can add 1 tablespoon of unsalted butter to 1 cup of whipping cream to mimic heavy cream. Likewise, if using Australian thickened cream, you’ll get extra insurance against over-whipping due to those gels and stabilisers in the ingredient list. But if you see “single cream” or “pouring cream” at the shops, put it back. Those are usually only about 18–25% fat and won’t give the cheesecake structure you want. It’s tempting to use whatever’s already in your fridge, but trust me: it’s a letdown when your cake refuses to hold up at the birthday party, melting all over the candles.

Want to make your cheesecake stand taller? Chill your bowl and beaters before whipping cream to keep everything as fluffy as possible. For baked cheesecakes, bring all your ingredients to room temperature, so the batter blends smooth and creamy, with no lumps. Always use a full-fat brick of cream cheese, never the spreadable kind. Don’t skip the step of tapping your filled pan on the bench to pop air bubbles—less air means less risk of cracks. If you live in a humid spot or your oven runs hot, bake your cheesecake in a water bath to slow the heating and keep that custard velvety all the way through. It’s worth taking the time for these fussy steps; they work like a charm.

Planning to go all out? Top your set cheesecake with whipped heavy cream and fresh berries. Or crush Tim Tams into the crust. In the heart of winter, swap in mulled wine-spiced poached pears. The backbone of every good cheesecake is the heavy cream or the closest quality alternative. If you can only find whipping cream, tweak the fat up a notch, and don’t be afraid to get creative with add-ins.

What about no-bake cheesecakes? They’re a slightly different beast. Whipping cream’s airiness is actually a plus since it keeps the filling light and mousse-like, with less concern for oven-baking structural strength. Still, even here, more fat means a more luxurious mouthfeel, and thickened cream’s additives help your cake set tall and proud in the fridge. So if you want that cloud-like finish, stick with whipping cream or even blend it with mascarpone. If you’re aiming for richness, lean into the thickened cream or add a bit of melted butter for good measure.

At the end of the day, it’s about the cheesecake you dream of making—and eating. Whether you’re after dense, bakery-style slices or lighter, airy bites, understanding your cream means you can finally stop second-guessing that dairy aisle and bring home a dessert people never forget. So next time you face the fridge, remember: heavy cream for richness and stability, whipping cream for lightness, and never be afraid to experiment—because in the world of cheesecake, there is no such thing as too much cream.